Using what you learned, respond to one of the following prompts and critique To Kill A Mockingbird using a critical lens.
- Through a feminist lens, discuss the characters of Scout and Mayella Ewell.
- Through a new historicism lens, discuss the trial of Tom Robinson.
- Through a marxist lens, discuss the social structures of Maycomb County.
Due by November 10 - Respond in the comments section below...click on "no comments" if the comment field does not show up.
| Credit will be given for | Extra Credit will be given for | No credit will be given |
|
|
|
|
| |
|
Through a feminist lens, Mayella Ewell is not a leader, she is a follower and is not a good example of a strong woman. Mayella is a follower in the way that she lets a man (her father) rule her and tell her what to do. Mayella is a follower because even though she knows what really happened with Tom Robinson, she listens to her father and tells the court what he wants her to say, that Tom Robinson "raped" her when Tom really is an innocent man. Mayella is also a follower in the way that she believes that blacks aren't equal to whites which is what most people in Macomb county believe, catching the Maycombs "usual disease". Scout on the other hand is totally opposite from Mayella. Scout, a leader, doesn't let people tell her what to do and a good example of a strong woman. Scout, doesn't let Jem and Dill overpower her and tell her what to do, she does whet she wants. When Atticus is at the county jail protecting Tom, Scout goes into the mob to help protect Atticus, showing she is a leader. Scout, doesn't believe that whites are more powerful than blacks and doesn't have the Maycombs "usual disease."
ReplyDeleteWhy do you think she lets her father lead her?
DeleteI think she lets her father tell her what to do and does what he tells her to do because, she is scared of what will happen if she doesn't do what he wants her to do. I am assuming this because of the way Tom heard Mr. Ewell talk to Mayella in the distance while escaping the Ewell property.
DeleteIn all honesty, Mayella Ewell attempted to be a leader by kissing Tom, however she cowered in the shadow of her father, and felt ashamed for being denied her kiss by a black man. She therefore tried to do the one thing that would get her rid of her shame, and be a higher human than she was said to be for not only attempting to kiss a black man, but being denied; "destroy the evidence", which she successfully did. She would probably not have her evidence destroyed, however, as you had said, "Mayella Ewell is not a leader", and she ended up following again, after all of her time trying to be a leader by trying to warm up to Tom Robinson, and trying to kiss him.
DeleteI agree with Sarah. It is true that Mayella let her father take advantage of her and is not very strong. Scout, however is.
DeleteI totally agree with why Mayella is not a leader. I believe that she doesn't get that much attention that is why she had to do what she did. Do you think that she could be a strong leader if she wanted to?
DeleteI agree with you and how you say Mayella is not a leader and how Scout is. Just like how in Josie's, when she said that Mayella cried when she wanted people to feel bad for her but leaders like Scout don't do that
DeleteTo Kill a Mockingbird was written in the 1960s, around the time of the Civil Rights movement. Through a New Historicism viewpoint, it can be said that the character Scout represents the author herself, Harper Lee. The author probably experienced some of these events like the trials and seeing blacks being treated unfairly which caused her to write sympathetically about Tom’s ordeal. Tom Robinson might represent the discrimination against blacks in that time period and the many trials before that in which they were wrongly accused. Bob Ewell and Mayella Ewell most likely represent the large amount of whites who discriminated and created laws to limit black’s power like the Jim Crow laws. In conclusion, looking through a New Historicism lens you can see that Harper Lee’s experiences influenced her writing in the book To Kill a Mockingbird.
ReplyDeleteI complete agree with the connections between each of the characters. I like how you made the connection with how she didn't like how blacks were being treated.
DeleteHannah Johnson's, mine, and (unknown) posted a historicism comment just as well, however we indicated the Scottsboro Boys, as this book was supposed to be in the 1930's in the Great Depression. However, I feel not that you were wrong, nor were we, however, I feel that both of ours are correct, as Harper Lee could've been trying to bring about awareness of the Civil Rights Movement by bringing back the (by then) the 30 year old case of racism against the African Americans. Therefore, I am saying that both your comment, and our comment are the basically the correct answer, however, together it would be about as strong as an answer could become.
DeleteI agree, who do you think people like Miss Stephanie and Mr Underwood would represent?
DeleteI agree, and i liked how you listed a lot of the characters and explain dhow they relate to real life people in the 1960s
DeleteTo Breanna:
DeleteMiss Stephanie might represent the typical lady in the 1930s; gossips, well dressed, and goes to the neighborhood parties with the other ladies. Mr. Underwood would represents the media who changes their views during the civil rights era against most of the unfair decisions.
Feminist Theory
ReplyDeleteBy: Sophia Kordas
In “To Kill A Mockingbird” a feminist theorist would see Scout and Mayella in two whole different ways. A feminist theorist could see Scout as an independent young lady that tries her best not to be a lady. Scout could be considered a mean person to the people she doesn't like. In the book you can tell that Scout is very nice to Miss. Maudie but the opposite to Miss Caroline or Mrs. Dubose. Also, in the book Scout gets offended if someone calls her a girl, because in the book men were stronger than girls . For Mayella they could see a young woman who is drawn to a man that she is not supposed to be drawn to. Mayella could be considered desperate for any man that comes her way or any man that gives an interest to her. For example, Tom Robinson. Tom is an African American man that is married but Mayella still tries to like him.
I completely agree with what your saying about Mayella. I like how you said she can be considered desperate for any man who comes her way.
DeleteDo you think the characters (Scout & Mayella) act so differently because of the way they where raised?
DeleteI disagree where you said "Scout tries her best not to be a lady." At the end of chapter 24, when they learn about Tom's death, Scout thinks, "If Aunt Alexandra can be a lady at a time like this, then so can I." Also, during the little tea parties Aunt Alexndra has, Scout is on her best manners and usually wears dresses.
DeleteI agree with you about scout not trying to be a lady and how sometimes she could be considered mean.
DeleteI agree with what you're saying about Scout (That she's independent) but I didn't think that Scout was necessarily being mean to Mrs.Caroline and Mrs.Dubose. She just didn't approve of their actions or opinions, like when Mrs.Dubose was making comments about the way she dressed.
DeleteThank you
DeleteI agree with what you said about Scout being mean to only the people she doesn't like. Do you think there is a reason that she acts this way?
DeleteWhy do you think that she is desperate?
DeleteWhy do you think that Scout is only nice to certain people?
DeleteThrough a feminist lens, Scout is not a stereotypical little girl. She is tough, and not afraid to share her opinions. In one situation, Scout punches Walter Cunningham when he gets her in trouble at school, instead of crying about it. On the other hand, Mayella Ewell does what she's not supposed to do, and crys when things don't go her way. When she is in court, she lies about what happened between her and Tom Robinson, and starts to sob when Atticus thinks she isn't telling the truth. This is how young women are often portrayed in literature.
ReplyDeleteI agree with this, but why do you think Mayella acts the way she does?
DeleteI completely agree with that statement, she is a tough girl and a stereotypical
DeleteI think your paragraph is very true. i like the thing with how Scout is stereotypical and tough
DeleteTo Breanna: I think Mayella acts this way because of her father and the way she was raised. Maybe if her father was more kind and loving, she wouldn't be so desperate for someone to love her. I think that when Tom Robinson helped her, she thought that it was because he had feelings for her, when really he was just trying to be nice.
DeleteI agree with this, as there is a reason as to why Scout would want to stick around with Jem; she wants to be tough, and not delicate like how woman are usually said to be.
DeleteI also agree with this paragraph because I like how it shows the differences between Scout and Mayella; that Scout is strong and unique and Mayella can be worn down very easily.
DeleteI agree with your paragraph and i liked how you explained why Scout isn't a stereotypical girl.
DeleteThis is a well written statement and I agree with everything you said. What do you think causes Scout to act the way she does? How do you think that her resistance to acting feminine will affect her in the future?
DeleteTo Alex: I think Scout acts this way because she doesn't really understand that women don't act the way she does. She is just being herself and she just happens to be a really tough, strong little girl. I think that when she grows she will either stay the way she is, or begin to act more and more ladylike. I say this because in a later chapter, she wears a dress and attends her Aunt Alexandra's missionary circle. This could mean that she is becoming more like a lady, but it's hard to say.
DeleteThe social structure consists of the people like the Finches on top, Cunninghams, blacks, Raymond's, and on the bottom, the Ewell's. People like the Finches are wealthy, the Cunninghams work hard for what they want but don't have the best of manners. The Raymond's are half black and half white, whites won't take them and neither will blacks. Therefore Mr. Raymond acts as a drunk to give people a reason for his actions. Maycomb is racist but the Ewell's are lower than the blacks because they live next to the dump and search through it everyday.
ReplyDeleteI agree with what your saying, but do you think that there are people higher on the social structure than people like the Finches?
DeleteI agree with Josie because there could be a family that we haven't heard much about in the story that are higher ranked than the finches such as judge Taylor's family . Even though we don't know much about them we can infer that his family is high ranked because he is the Judge of Maycomb County .
DeleteTo Hannah & Josie: I agree with what you're saying, but I wasn't sure because we didn't get a big description of his life. I felt he would be on top of the social structure of Maycomb from his description so far.
DeleteThrough a Marxist lens, the Finches would be at the top of the popularity and wealthy class. the classes consist of the Finches being at the top then the Radilys, then the Cunningham's, then the Ewells, and at the bottom of the class would be the black community. this shows that the Finches are very respected and looked up to in this novel.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you when you said the Finches are very respected, but I'm pretty sure the book mentioned that the Ewells are lower in class than the black community.
DeleteI agree with Josie on that part but I also think that you should have added something about the Raymond's since they are different than most of the people in Maycomb because they have both African Americans and whites in there family .
DeleteI agree with you when you said the finches are respected and looked up to
DeleteI agree with Hannah and Josie because racism is a very important part of the book, as well as the Ewell's being below the Robinson's.
DeleteI agree with what both Josie and Hannah said but I am interested in why you put the Radleys second in your list of classes. I can see why because of the fact that they mind there own business and Boo Radley is an innocent man or a "Mockingbird," but the book did mention that their house is run down with a sort of creepy feeling which you can infer that it is old. Also Mr. Radley was rude toward blacks which means he is racist. I can see both points of view but I most likely would have put them as a middle to lower class.
DeleteI agree with Hannah, the Raymonds were definitely apart of the Maycomb social pyramid but where they stand is questionable because they are a mixed family.
DeleteI agree because the Marxist theory separates people by their how much money they have, and Ewells may have less money but more respect over blacks because there white.
DeleteJosie,
Deleteracism is apart of this novel and the Ewells are higher in the class system because of that.
thanks.
I agree because the Finches represent the top of the chart through a Marxist lens.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteFrom a new historicism lens the book To Kill a Mockingbird was written in the the early 1930s when America was suffering from the Great Depression and the issue of civil rights. The Scottsboro brothers case also took place during this time . The author Harper Lee could have related the Tom Robinson trial to the Scottsboro brothers trial and that Scout, Dill, and Jem are all bystanders watching the trial , that judge Taylor is Judge Horton , Tom Robinson is the group of nine black teens that were being accused of rape and not given a fair trial , that Mayella and her father Mr. Ewell , are like the two girls who accused the teens of rape and that Atticus is related to the lawyer who has to defend the African American boys .
ReplyDeleteI agree with the timing and your description of the time period. I like how you made the connection with the article of the Scottsboro Boys trial and using great supporting details, it really showed that you understood the connection between the article and the book and the timing of when this occurred.
DeleteI think that this is a very good analogy with the the Scottsboro boys. Who do you think that the crowds of black and white people sitting in the gallery most likely represent in Harper Lee's life?
DeleteI agree with this, as all of this makes sense, as this book was written to be within that time frame while those occurrences did occur.
DeleteI do have a question, though. By indicating that Scout, Dill, and Jem were all bystanders watching the trail, were you indicating that they were indeed at the courtroom at the time, watching it, or were they in their home, living through the times of racial discrimination, and hearing about the Scottsboro Boys, although not actually watching it at the courtroom?
DeleteI agree with you because Tom Robinson is related to the Scottsboro boys in the way that they were both treated unfairly in their trials.
DeleteThe trial of Tom Robinson can be viewed through a New Historicism lens in many ways. To start the time frame in which the trial took place in was in the 1930’s.The time frame was during the Great Depression, the time where blacks were not treated equally compared to whites. Due to this, the event tells us that blacks were still treated unfairly when the verdict is announced. The court rules in Mayella Ewell’s favor, and Tom is guilty of the rape and abuse of Mayella. In addition to the the view of the New Historicism lens, the trial also connects to the trial of the Scottsboro boys in 1931. In the Scottsboro boys trial the 9 African American teenagers were accused of the rape of two teenage white american girls on a train. After the case and many others like it, most African Americans were then stereotyped and not trusted, causing jurors to take the side of the white victim. In conclusion, the trial of Tom Robinson can be viewed through a New Historicism lens in many ways.
ReplyDeleteI like how you made the connection with the Scottsboro brothers and the part where you said that the people would vote against them.
DeleteI agree with what you are saying. I thinks that the Civil Rights movement also plays a part in why Harper Lee wrote about the trial in the way she did (making you feel sympathy for Tom).
DeleteShelby Hey
ReplyDeleteThe trial of Tom Robinson can be classified through a new historicism lense because it was during the period of the Great Depression (1930’s). Tom Robinson was described as a “dangerous” person because he received 30 days for disorderly conduct. Throughout our history blacks have never been treated fairly. Tom Robinson was charged with the rape and harm done to Mayella Ewell and went to prison. Tom Robinson's trial can also relate to the Scottsboro Boys trial because they were both accused of rape, arrested and we're both in the 1930’s. They were both unfair trials because white people were racist and they had an all white jury for the boys case. To conclude Tom Robinson's case can be classified as a new historicisim theory because people were unfair to blacks and didn't think of them as people.
By Kristof Pawelek
ReplyDeleteHistoricism
Through a New Historicism lens, Tom Robinson’s trial shows a relation with the Scottsboro Boys case where the defendant was declared guilty when the defendant was obviously innocent. In the book, Atticus had shown many key details in the trial, which made it clear and obvious that the defendant was innocent. In the Scottsboro Boys case, it was said that the prosecuting side literally admitted that the Scottsboro Boys did not rape the girls, but only looked at them funny, nonetheless, in both cases the defendant was proven guilty due to their color, and the racism of the south, just as well as the social structure of the time this book was taking place; in the 1930’s during the Great Depression, where the African Americans were below white men, no matter what, and if the southerners got the chance, they would prosecute the African Americans.
ReplyDeleteScout Finch and Mayella Ewell in “To Kill A Mockingbird” are very different women when looking through a feminist lens. Scout is an independent woman who is considered a tomboy. She wears overalls instead of dresses, likes to play outdoors with Jem and Dill, and for the most part speaks her mind. Aunt Alexandra is always saying that is not right that Scout is allowed to run around and not have to act like a proper girl. Scout does not like when people call her a girl like it’s a bad thing because that means that she is different than boys/men who are treated with more respect. Mayella is a lonely girl that does not try to do much to be treated as an equal. She does what people expect girls to do, like cry when they don’t get what they want. Mayella lied and made a sense to try and convince people of what “happened” between her and Tom Robinson. When Bob Ewell talks about Mayella it is the she fragile and can not do things for herself, which is how women in the past are represented for the most part.
Why do you think Mayella lets her father speak about her in such a way?
DeleteGet rid of how Mayella relates to men in her life and this is a great response.
DeleteIn the book To Kill A Mockingbird Mayella and Scout are clearly two different characters. Scout is a girl but likes to be a tom-boy she likes to get dirty and doesn't like wearing fancy outfits she also likes to be rough and isn't sensitive like most girls her age would be. Mayella is more of a lady and tries to be lady-like even though she doesn't live in a clean environment also Mayella is way more sensitive than Scout. One example of this is that Scout doesn't cry when she is under pressure but Mayella on the under hand does,for example when was in court and Atticus asked her certain questions. As you can see this is how people would look through a feminist lens and how Scout and Mayella are different.
ReplyDeleteBy:Maren
In the book To Kill A Mockingbird Mayella and Scout are clearly two different characters. Scout is a girl but likes to be a tom-boy she likes to get dirty and doesn't like to wearing fancy outfits she also likes to be rough and isn't sensitive like most girls her age would be. Mayella is more of a lady and tries to be lady-like even though she doesn't live in a clean environment also Mayella is way more sensitive than Scout. One example of this is that Scout doesn't cry when she is under pressure but Mayella on the other hand does, for example when she was in court and Atticus asked her certain questions. As you can tell this is how tell this is how people would look in a feminist lens and see how Mayella and Scout are different.
ReplyDeleteThrough a new historicism lens, the trial of Tom Robinson would be considered unfair and unjust. This was because he was thought to be from an inferior race. Today, everyone is considered equal in the eyes of the law and is entitled to a fair trial. Another example of this type of racism was 9 African-American boys were accused of raping 2 white girls on a train. This was the trial of the Scottsboro boys, which was was also around the time To Kill A Mockingbird took place (1931) . Although the girls were lying, the boys were still punished. They also didn't get a fair trial, just like Tom Robinson.
ReplyDeleteI agree you did a good job I liked how you related it with the Scottsboro Boys.
DeleteWhen looking at Maycomb through a Marxist lens it is important to view the social structures of the county. The majority of the people who live there could be considered middle to lower class. For example, the Ewells could fit in the lower class category based on their lifestyle, living conditions, and interactions toward people. More specifically, based on the evidence of the trial, Bob Ewell was the one who raped Mayella, his own daughter showing his lower social class behaviors. On the other hand, the Finches represent the middle to upper class based on Atticus' job as a lawyer along with their ability to live in a better neighborhood compared to the Ewells. Overall these examples show the differences in social structures of Maycomb county.
ReplyDeleteWhen looking at Maycomb through a Marxist lens it is important to view the social structures of the County. The majority of the people who live there could be considered middle to lower class. For example, the Ewells could fit in the lower class category based on their lifestyle, living conditions, and interactions toward people. More specifically, based on the evidence of the trial, Bob Ewell was the one who raped Mayella, his own daughter showing his lower social class behaviors. On the other hand, the Finches represent the middle to upper class based on Atticus' job as a lawyer along with their ability to live in a better neighborhood compared to the Ewells. Overall, these examples show the differences in social structures of Maycomb County.
ReplyDeleteGood job, your description of the way the Finch's and the Ewells' live is very thorough and makes a lot of sense.
DeleteThrough a new historicism view, Tom Robinson relates to the nine Scottsboro boys because they were both weare black and accused of something they didn't do, but were found guilty by the judge and were punished. This shows the racism that our country had during the 1930s, which was when blacks struggled for equality. Atticus mentions the quote by Ben Franklin about all men being created equal in his speech. Unfortunately, this is a very unpopular thought. The majority of Maycomb's population is racist; Mr. Cunningham was the only one willing to vote in favor of Tom during the case. Also, even though the Ewells are more disgusting and poor than the Robinsons, the Robinsons are still considers under the Ewells in the society of Maycomb's. This is only because the Robinsons are black, and the Ewells are white. This is all because of what time period the event occurred. That is why the Ewells won the case and the two white girls from the Scottsboro Boys won their case.
ReplyDeleteThrough a new historicism view, Tom Robinson relates to the nine Scottsboro boys because they were both weare black and accused of something they didn't do, but were found guilty by the judge and were punished. This shows the racism that our country had during the 1930s, which was when blacks struggled for equality. Atticus mentions the quote by Ben Franklin about all men being created equal in his speech. Unfortunately, this is a very unpopular thought. The majority of Maycomb's population is racist; Mr. Cunningham was the only one willing to vote in favor of Tom during the case. Also, even though the Ewells are more disgusting and poor than the Robinsons, the Robinsons are still considers under the Ewells in the society of Maycomb's. This is only because the Robinsons are black, and the Ewells are white. This is all because of what time period the event occurred. That is why the Ewells won the case and the two white girls from the Scottsboro Boys won their case.
ReplyDeleteIn To Kill A Mockingbird, through a marxist lens, readers can see that there are ranks of economic and behavioral class in the community starting at the top with the Finches. The Finches are viewed at the top because Atticus is a honest, hard working man in the strong position of being a lawyer and he raises his children well teaching them good morals and behaviors. Next on the “social-ladder” comes the Cunninghams because although the family is poor, they work hard for what they earn and do not accept anything they cannot pay back. After the Cunninghams come the Raymonds because they are a mixed family and are socially rejected by both the black and the white communities. The Robinson family falls next on the caste system of Maycomb County because they are a hardworking family that is discriminated and rejected based on the color of their skin by the racist people of Maycomb County. Lastly comes the Ewells because even though they are racially viewed as better than blacks, their economic standings and behavioral choices set them lower than the black community from a marxist standpoint.
ReplyDeleteIn To Kill A Mockingbird, through a marxist lens, readers can see that there are ranks of economic and behavioral class in the community starting at the top with the Finches. The Finches are viewed at the top because Atticus is a honest, hard working man in the strong position of being a lawyer and he raises his children well teaching them good morals and behaviors. Next on the “social-ladder” comes the Cunninghams because although the family is poor, they work hard for what they earn and do not accept anything they cannot pay back. After the Cunninghams come the Raymonds because they are a mixed family and are socially rejected by both the black and the white communities. The Robinson family falls next on the caste system of Maycomb County because they are a hardworking family that is discriminated and rejected based on the color of their skin by the racist people of Maycomb County. Lastly comes the Ewells because even though they are racially viewed as better than blacks, their economic standings and behavioral choices set them lower than the black community from a marxist standpoint.
ReplyDeleteI agree, however weren't the Ewell respected by many whites as compared to Robinsons, and the Raymonds?
DeleteYour response is very educated and thorough, you really reveal your point with great adjectives and description of the "social classes." Great job.
DeleteThey were, but as viewed through a Marxist lens, the Ewells fell below the blacks and the Raymonds based on their financial status.
DeleteTo: Kristof Pawelek
By: Simone Neivel
ReplyDeleteThrough a Feminist lens, male traits rub off onto Scout because you see that she does not act or do things like a lady. Scout wears overalls every day and refuses to wear dresses, things that people would not expect from a girl. For example, Aunt Alexandra moves into Scout’s house because she believes that Scout needs a feminine influence. On the other hand, Mayella does not get enough attention by anyone therefore she attacks Tom Robinson. In the book it states that Mayella said, “I have never kissed a grown man but it might as well be a black.” Scout and Mayella are totally different when it comes to looking in the eyes of a feminist.
Through a Feminist lens, male traits rub off onto Scout because you see that she does not act or do things like a lady. Scout wears overalls every day and refuses to wear dresses, things that people would not expect from a girl. For example, Aunt Alexandra moves into Scout’s house because she believes that Scout needs a feminine influence. On the other hand, Mayella does not get enough attention by anyone therefore she attacks Tom Robinson. In the book it states that Mayella said, “I have never kissed a grown man but it might as well be a black.” Scout and Mayella are totally different when it comes to looking in the eyes of a feminist.
ReplyDeleteLooking at To Kill a Mockingbird in a Feminist lens, the two main female characters, Mayella and Scout, are very different. Despite growing up in a disheveled environment, Mayella seems to care more about her appearance than the other Ewells, and the red flowers that she tends to are a very feminine symbol. Mayella cried in court for pity, and is far from boyish. On the contrary, Scout was written to be a more boyish character. Even with feminine influences, she still prefers to wear overalls over dresses. She's very outspoken, and has a tough aura about her, but this could be from growing up with Jem and Dill. These differences between the characters may exist because of the drastic age difference. It's possible that as Scout becomes older, she loses her "tomboy" attitude on life.
ReplyDeleteThrough a new histocrism lens the Tom Robinson trial and the Scottsboro boys are the same because there both accused of rape. And both cases have no chance to win in court. When Atticus tells scout the were already lick that proves that Tom had no chance to win in court because he is black. The Scottsboro boys had no chance because they were black. And in the end both Tom Robinson and the Scottsboro boys die horrible tragic deaths because of racism.
ReplyDeleteThrough a new histocrism lens the Tom Robinson trial and the Scottsboro boys are the same because there both accused of rape. And both cases have no chance to win in court. When Atticus tells scout the were already lick that proves that Tom had no chance to win in court because he is black. The Scottsboro boys had no chance because they were black. And in the end both Tom Robinson and the Scottsboro boys die horrible tragic deaths because of racism.
ReplyDeleteThrough a new historical lens, Tom Robinson’s trial from To Kill A Mockingbird is thought of as a normal trial for that time period. This event has been interpreted as a specific one out of many that were happening in the Southern U.S. around 1930s, when this book takes place. It is interpreted this way because around that time period, in the South, segregation was a big part of society, it’s not just Maycomb County that is racist and segregated, it’s all of the Southern United States. The way it is interpreted shows that the people who understand it aren’t racist and DO NOT have a segregated society. The reason trials were like this in the Southern U.S. is because most people didn’t like the African-American race in the 1930s and through a new historicism lens it makes sense that people acted this way, although it wouldn’t be accepted in this day and age. Overall, through a new historical lens, Tom’s trial from the story is thought of as a normal trial for the time period.
DeleteThere are a couple grammar and spelling mistakes that are visible but they don't effect your point, so good job.
DeleteThrough a new historical lens, Tom Robinson’s trial from To Kill A Mockingbird is thought of as a normal trial for that time period. This event has been interpreted as a specific one out of many that were happening in the Southern U.S. around 1930s, when this book takes place. It is interpreted this way because around that time period, in the South, segregation was a big part of society, it’s not just Maycomb County that is racist and segregated, it’s all of the Southern United States. The way it is interpreted shows that the people who understand it aren’t racist and DO NOT have a segregated society. The reason trials were like this in the Southern U.S. is because most people didn’t like the African-American race in the 1930s and through a new historicist lens it makes sense that people acted this way, although it wouldn’t be accepted in this day and age. Overall, through a new historical lens, Tom’s trial from the story is thought of as a normal trial for the time period.
ReplyDeleteBraden Lynch
ReplyDeleteThrough a Marxist lens, the Finches come first. A Marxist lens is looking at a person or a group of people by there economics and behavior. Atticus is a well rounded person and shows Jem and Scout the way and how to be a good person. Next comes the Cunninghams who are hardworking people, who may not have the most money in Maycomb, but works for every single penny. Next comes the Raymond's who is a family of blacks and whites, but neither races accept the Raymond's. Next is the Robinson family, who works very hard but is not accepted by whites and is treated very unfairly. Lastly is the Ewell's, who may be white, but there economic and behaviors set them last through a marxist lens.
From a New Historicism Theory, Tom Robinson’s trial is like most trials that happened during the 1930, unfair because of race. Even though during the trial Atticus makes many points on why Tom should be set free, but because Tom was African American and whites were “superior” over them Tom lost his case. This would happen because during the 1930s there was segregation, besides Tom’s case all together the courtroom was segregated all the whites (minus Mr. Raymond, Dill, Scout, and Jem) sat up front, while all the African Americans sat in the balconies behind the white seats. Today, this case would have a complete different verdict because of the Civil Rights Act of 1864 that ended segregation in the U.S. Today the African Americans whites, and all other races were treated the same so Tom would of been set free.
ReplyDeleteFrom a New Historicism Theory, Tom Robinson’s trial is like most trials that happened during the 1930, unfair because of race. Even though during the trial Atticus makes many points on why Tom should be set free, but because Tom was African American and whites were “superior” over them Tom lost his case. This would happen because during the 1930s there was segregation, besides Tom’s case all together the courtroom was segregated all the whites (minus Mr. Raymond, Dill, Scout, and Jem) sat up front, while all the African Americans sat in the balconies behind the white seats. Today, this case would have a complete different verdict because of the Civil Rights Act of 1864 that ended segregation in the U.S. Today the African Americans whites, and all other races were treated the same so Tom would of been set free.
ReplyDeleteThrough a feminist point of view, Scout Finch and Mayella Ewell are treated like, or expected to act like women of that time period, lady like and fragile. However deep down they wanted to be themselves. Independent and strong.
ReplyDeleteTo start, Scout prefers to hang out with boys instead of girls her age. For example, Scout would rather be pushed down a tire then play with dolls like what people expect her to do. Next, Mayella Ewell is fighting herself hatred for liking and acting out adult desires for a black man. In the time period that was an unspeakable thing for a respectful white young lady to do.
Throughout the book these two young ladies continue to fight what is expected of them by society. Either through a conscious debate like Mayella or outwardly like Scout.
Scout Finch and Mayella Ewell in “To Kill A Mockingbird” are very different women when looking through a feminist lense. Scout is an independent woman who is considered a tomboy. She wears overalls instead of dresses, likes to play outdoors with Jem and Dill, and for the most part speaks her mind. Aunt Alexandra is always saying that is not right that Scout is allowed to run around and not have to act like a proper girl. Scout does not like when people call her a girl like it’s a bad thing because that means that she is different than boys/men who are treated with more respect. Mayella is a lonely girl that does not try to do much to be treated as an equal. She does what people expect girls to do, like cry when they don’t get what they want. Mayella lied and made a sense to try and convince people of what “happened” between her and Tom Robinson. When Bob Ewell talks about Mayella it is the she fragile and can not do things for herself, which is how women in the past are represented for the most part.
ReplyDelete